Go Back   SOCNET: The Special Operations Community Network > U.S. Marine Corps Special Operations > MarSoc

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 24 January 2008, 16:02
MailBuoy MailBuoy is offline
Confirmed User
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Planet Earth
Posts: 121
Colonel again criticizes Marines in shooting

I loved this part;

"Leaving the scene of a gunfight is "something we never do," Nicholson said archly, stressing that his Army brigade was trained to "remain in possession of the battlefield."

The Marines undermined investigations into the shootings, Nicholson said, by fleeing the scene rather than staying to treat casualties and preserve evidence."


So the next time your convoy gets ambushed don't get off the 'X', stay there, treat the enemy's casualties, and pick up spent shell casings.

Colonel again criticizes Marines in shooting

Army officer John Nicholson, who said last year he was 'deeply ashamed' that U.S. troops had killed Afghan civilians, testifies that the unit involved did not keep him informed of its actions.

By David Zucchino, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer
January 24, 2008

CAMP LEJEUNE, N.C. -- -- In May, Army Col. John Nicholson created an uproar when he said he was "deeply ashamed" that U.S. Marines had killed Afghan civilians during an incident two months earlier. Marine commanders said Nicholson was wrong to denounce the Marines while investigations were still underway.

On Wednesday, Nicholson again criticized the Marines, this time during a Marine Corps court of inquiry investigating the March 4 incident. A Marine special operations unit has been accused of shooting civilians indiscriminately after a car-bomb attack on its convoy.

Speaking by video link from the Pentagon, Nicholson said the Marine unit often strayed outside its assigned area and did not coordinate with him even though he was the area "battle space" commander. He said he was not informed that the unit was on a mission the day of the shootings.

The Marines undermined investigations into the shootings, Nicholson said, by fleeing the scene rather than staying to treat casualties and preserve evidence.

Leaving the scene of a gunfight is "something we never do," Nicholson said archly, stressing that his Army brigade was trained to "remain in possession of the battlefield."

Nicholson's pointed testimony underscored tensions between Army and Marine commanders in eastern Afghanistan even before Marine Special Operations Company F encountered the car bomb. The Marine unit, the first Marine special operations company deployed in combat, was ordered out of Afghanistan shortly after the shootings.

In May, Nicholson told reporters that 19 civilians had been killed and 50 wounded. He said he was "terribly sorry that Americans have killed and wounded innocent Afghan people." In his testimony Wednesday, Nicholson described having to repair carefully nurtured relations with local Pashtun tribes after the shootings. He said the incident compromised his counterinsurgency efforts.

Several Marines have testified at the inquiry, now in its third week, that Humvee gunners adhered to military rules of engagement and shot at gunmen who opened fire on the convoy as part of a "complex ambush." Shortly before the shootings, the American convoy had been struck by a van packed with explosives, slightly wounding one Marine.

Nicholson testified that the commander of the Marine unit, Maj. Fred C. Galvin, kept him in the darkabout his unit's actions. Galvin reported to a special operations command, but Nicholson commanded an Army brigade and was in charge of the battle space. The colonel said he'd told Galvin to coordinate actions with him.

Nicholson said he found out after the incident that Galvin had conducted more than 30 operations in Nicholson's eastern Afghanistan command area but had told him of just five or six.

Nicholson's focus was on "the human terrain," he said, whereas the Marines seemed intent on tracking and killing insurgents. He said he stressed combat coordination because "you can't just roll into the battle space unannounced."

The court is investigating the actions of Galvin and the convoy commander, Capt. Vincent J. Noble. It will report its findings to a Marine general. No one has been charged.

Nicholson said Galvin told him just after the shootings that his men had come under fire at the car-bomb site and fired back, leaving "five or six bodies." Galvin said the 30-man convoy was fired on again farther down the highway and again returned fire.

Pressed by civilian lawyers representing Galvin and Noble, Nicholson acknowledged that the number of dead and wounded has not been established and that U.S. troops who arrived on the scene 30 minutes after the car bombing found no dead or wounded Afghans.

But Nicholson said Afghans collect and bury their dead quickly, in accordance with Muslim traditions. And he said the highway where the shootings took place leads directly to a hospital in nearby Jalalabad.

Asked whether Taliban insurgents often "seed" battlefields with phony civilian casualties or exaggerate civilian deaths, Nicholson replied: "That's why it's so important for us to stay on the scene."

david.zucchino@latimes.com
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 24 January 2008, 16:09
Massgrunt's Avatar
Massgrunt Massgrunt is offline
Violent Social Worker
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Day shift.
Posts: 11,466
Quote:
Originally Posted by MailBuoy
I loved this part;

[I]"Leaving the scene of a gunfight is "something we never do," Nicholson said archly, stressing that his Army brigade was trained to "remain in possession of the battlefield."

The Marines undermined investigations into the shootings, Nicholson said, by fleeing the scene rather than staying to treat casualties and preserve evidence.
Easy for him to say from the comfort of his office.
__________________
"The real problem was being able to stick it out, to sit in an office under the orders of a wee man in a dark gray suit and look out of the window and recall the bush country, the waving palms, the smell of sweat and cordite, the grunts of the men hauling jeeps over the river crossings, the copper-tasting fears just before the attack, and the wild, cruel joy of being alive afterward. To remember, and then go back to the ledgers and the commuter train, that was impossible. He knew he would eat his heart out if it ever came to that."

- "The Dogs of War" by Frederick Forsyth
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 24 January 2008, 17:15
The Corporate Guy's Avatar
The Corporate Guy The Corporate Guy is offline
All Labs Matter
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Virtual Panopticon
Posts: 4,199
Quote:
Originally Posted by MailBuoy

"Colonel again criticizes Marines in shooting

CAMP LEJEUNE, N.C. -- --

In May, Nicholson told reporters that 19 civilians had been killed and 50 wounded...

...Pressed by civilian lawyers representing Galvin and Noble, Nicholson acknowledged that the number of dead and wounded has not been established and that U.S. troops who arrived on the scene 30 minutes after the car bombing found no dead or wounded Afghans.

But Nicholson said Afghans collect and bury their dead quickly, in accordance with Muslim traditions.
Seems like a bit of a disconnect there...
__________________
I find it rather easy to portray a businessman. Being bland, rather cruel and incompetent comes naturally to me. John Cleese
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 24 January 2008, 17:32
Silverbullet's Avatar
Silverbullet Silverbullet is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Bunker
Posts: 14,095
What a putz.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 24 January 2008, 17:57
CPTAUSRET's Avatar
CPTAUSRET CPTAUSRET is offline
BTDT
 
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Iowa City, Iowa...
Posts: 9,190
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silverbullet
What a putz.

Yup!

Really bad form!
__________________
"IF THOU STRIKETH THE KING, STRIKE NOT TO WOUND":
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 24 January 2008, 18:46
iraqgunz's Avatar
iraqgunz iraqgunz is offline
Overseas Gunplumber
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Warm and sunny Arizona
Posts: 5,812
Ok, let me get this straight. When ambushed or receiving fire you are supposed to remain on scene so they can continue to shoot at you. That's a new one. If we apply this standard to Iraq is Colonel Fuckstick going to say that every Army unit in Iraq stays on scene and "preserves evidence" and treats the wounded?

It's not a crime scene it a damn war. Maybe he needs to join the highway patrol.
__________________
"The Armies of our ancestors were lucky, in that they were not trailed by a second army of pencil pushers".

I have been to some armorer courses.

Owner- Semper Paratus Arms, LLC
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 24 January 2008, 19:11
Massgrunt's Avatar
Massgrunt Massgrunt is offline
Violent Social Worker
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Day shift.
Posts: 11,466
Any contractors remember the push to make teams stay on scene to treat wounded until the military showed up?
__________________
"The real problem was being able to stick it out, to sit in an office under the orders of a wee man in a dark gray suit and look out of the window and recall the bush country, the waving palms, the smell of sweat and cordite, the grunts of the men hauling jeeps over the river crossings, the copper-tasting fears just before the attack, and the wild, cruel joy of being alive afterward. To remember, and then go back to the ledgers and the commuter train, that was impossible. He knew he would eat his heart out if it ever came to that."

- "The Dogs of War" by Frederick Forsyth
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 24 January 2008, 20:06
Greenhat
Visitor
 
Posts: n/a
Anybody know what this guy's background is?

It was an SOF unit. If it'd been an ODA or a SEAL Platoon, would he actually expect them to stay on the site of a firefight in all circumstances?

One solution fits all?
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 24 January 2008, 20:33
0802 0802 is offline
Authorized Personnel
 
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: In B-Billet Hell
Posts: 292
He is the CO of TF Spartan.

Most of the Marines in my office equate his statements to why we are going to loose this war. Since when is evidence collected in a war? When you have BCT commanders wanting to fight this war as if they were police than you will never win.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 24 January 2008, 22:58
murdog murdog is offline
civilian hater
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: overland park, ks
Posts: 77
Damn, I went to high school with Fred Galvin.
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 24 January 2008, 23:35
Remington Raider's Avatar
Remington Raider Remington Raider is offline
True Origin Not Known
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: peanut gallery
Posts: 1,926
Damn jarheads!

Quote:
Originally Posted by MailBuoy
Nicholson's focus was on "the human terrain," he said, whereas the Marines seemed intent on tracking and killing insurgents.
First comes president Hilary, then comes this guy's star. All O's are part politician. This guy is 100 percent. Glad he could take the time to appear by videoconference, cause he is probably SO busy coordinating . . . whatever he coordinates.
__________________
Wolves and alligators should be cross-bred to make wolfagators that will be silent and fast, and we'll never have to hear from those people, they will just be wolfagator shit.
-Eltrane

Are you fucking serious? That's the most ridiculous thing I've heard all week...and I'm at a senior staff planning conference, so, the bar has been set pretty high. You should be proud. - Gavin
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 25 January 2008, 02:33
islandrecce12 islandrecce12 is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: IQ
Posts: 11
"Galvin reported to a special operations command, but Nicholson commanded an Army brigade and was in charge of the battle space. "

Sounds like a Army officer is a little but hurt that the Marine SOF was operating in his space from the start. Excactly what MARSOC is going to encounter everywhere they operate
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 25 January 2008, 03:10
Flying Pig's Avatar
Flying Pig Flying Pig is offline
Confirmed User
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: SW Florida
Posts: 3,417
So now Marines are carrying yellow crime scene tape in their packs?
__________________
Conduct every traffic stop extending the olive branch of peace; while having a tactical plan to kill everyone inside the vehicle. - Gordon Graham
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 25 January 2008, 06:53
SN's Avatar
SN SN is offline
Old and Broke
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: The GREAT State of Texas
Posts: 4,565
His testimony will exonerate the Marines, and expose him as a qualified staff guy, vice Combat Leader.
__________________
FISHDO
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 25 January 2008, 15:37
Longrifle's Avatar
Longrifle Longrifle is offline
Sound off for equipment check!
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Pergo per caligo...
Posts: 5,356
Sure simplifies Immediate Action Drills:
Near ambush - remain in KZ, return fire.
Far ambush - remain in KZ, return fire.


Oh, and think up a better name for a kill zone. Like, crime scene? That's it.

Remain at crime scene, return fire.


__________________
The Constitution is not an instrument for the government to restrain the people, it is an instrument for the people to restrain the government - lest it come to dominate our lives and interests. ~Patrick Henry

"Sēlre bi ghwm t hē his frēond wrece, onne hē fela murne." ~Bēowulf, bearn Ecgēowes
Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old 25 January 2008, 17:54
Pickpocket Pickpocket is offline
Confirmed User
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Houston
Posts: 178
Quote:
Originally Posted by islandrecce12
Sounds like a Army officer is a little but hurt that the Marine SOF was operating in his space from the start.
Got that impression, did you? Was it from the 10 different statements he made stressing that "he was in charge of the battlespace" or was it from his repeated insistence that the big mean Marine wasn't telling him what was going on in his own back yard?

Yeah...this guy's a tool.
__________________
Semper Fi -
Dave

McCain 2008:
Because if we have to have a liberal Democrat in the White House, he might as well be a Republican.
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 25 January 2008, 21:30
HOLLiS HOLLiS is offline
Confirmed User
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Rural, Oregon
Posts: 469
His quote, "pick up spent shell casings."

That was out biggest fear in RVN, that the war would end during our tour. They would stand us on line at the D and have us walking south policing the area.

I think my Gunny would say something about the Col having a major malfunction, in a very respectul manner.
Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old 25 January 2008, 23:31
MailBuoy MailBuoy is offline
Confirmed User
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Planet Earth
Posts: 121
If I were the defence attorney (I play one on tv);

'Colonel, earlier you stated that your brigade was trained to remain in possession of the battlefield, correct?'

Nicholson; 'That is correct'

'So Colonel, when ambushed your unit is trained to never break contact?'

N; 'Well, it depends on the element size. I am talking about the whole brigade'

'So you are saying this MARSOC element has the combat power of your entire brigade, right?'

N; 'Of course not, I meant MY brigade would retain possession of the battlefield'

'So this six vehicle convoy has the same capabilities of your brigade, or, you would expect them to attempt to attain an endstate that you would expect from your brigade?'

N; 'Of course not, that small an element does not have that kind of combat power'

'But you stated, and I quote you; "Leaving the scene of a gunfight is something we NEVER do"' Do you mean when your entire brigade is moving in convoy and are attacked they will retain control of the battlefield?'

N; 'Er, yes, I mean no.'

'What about only one of of your battalions? If they are ambushed do they retain control of the battlefield?'

N; 'Of course.'

'When was the last time one of your battalions was ambushed?'

N; 'Well, two weeks previous to this incident a platoon from Gulf Company, with some MPs attached was.....'

'No, when was the last time one of your battalions was ambushed?'

N; 'I was trying to tell you....'

'No, when was one of your ENTIRE battalions moving in a convoy was ambushed?'

N; 'I've never had an entire battalion moving in a convoy'

'I'm confused, you said that your BRIGADE was trained to retain possession of the battlefield, yet none of your battalions has ever moved in mass.'

N; 'No, we move in smaller elements so...'

'What does this have to do with basically a platoon of Marines moving in a six vehicle in a convoy? You said your BRIGADE would retain possession of the battlefield. Can your entire brigade fit into six vehicles?'

N; 'Well, no, that is silly.'

'But if your brigade was ambushed you would retain possession of the battlefield, correct?'

N; 'Most assuradly.'

'So if you had, say, a squad on patrol in two vehicle and they were ambushed by 40 or 50 Taliban your squad should stay and retain possession of the battlefield regardless of casualties, right?'

N; 'I never said that! I never said that!'

'Colonel, earlier you stated that your brigade was trained to remain in possession of the battlefield, correct?'

N; 'That's my brigade, my whole brigade.'

'So when was the last time your entire brigade moved in convoy?'

N; 'Well, never.'

'So a squad is not expected to retain control of the battlefield?'

N; 'Well, yes, I mean if they can, yes, sure they HAVE to (under his breath) goddam Marines.'

'Now that you are at the Pentagon I am sure we can see FM 55-30, Army Motor Transport Units and Operations rewritten, right?'

N; 'What?'

'FM 55-30, Army Motor Transport Units and Operations Section 6.4 titled 'Ambush' states; "That part of the convoy that is in the kill zone and receiving fire must exit the kill zone as quickly as possible if the road to the front is open." So based on your comabt proven experience this is incorrect and will be rectified in the near future, right?'

N; 'No, I don't know what you are talking about.'

'Colonel Nicholson, I have here a copy of the combat SOP for 3rd Brigade, 10th Mountain Division, are you familiar with this document?'

N; 'Certainly, I wrote it.'

'Can you show me in this document where the chow hall is?'

N; 'What?'

'Nevermind. Can you show me in this document where it states that all combat elements, regardless of size, will retain control of the battlefield when engaged?'

N; 'No, that is standard stuff in MY brigade. Everyone knows that.'

'Ok, Colonel, now where in this document does it state that an unit that is engaged should treat the enemies casualties and gather evidence? Is that right after where it DOES NOT state that an engaged element should always maintain control of the battlefield?'

N; 'No, it doesn't say that, but, er, everyone knows that, except Marines, they think they are...., well, they didn't tell me what they were..., no, but....'

'Question withdrawn, the witness is excused...., oh, wait, one more question, sorry.'

N; 'Alright'

'Colonel, how many vehicles where in your brigade the day the MARSOC element was engaged?'

N; 'Uh, I have no idea. I can get back to you on that....'

'Colonel, actually I have your unit's SITREP for that day. I count a total of 743 vehicles, is that correct?'

N; 'Ah, it sounds correct but....'

'How many men were present in your brigade that day?'

N; 'Uh, I am a Colonel, I have minions to track that stuff.'

'Again Colonel, here's your unit's SITREP for March 4, 2007. Your brigade had 2,443 personnel present that day to include attachments, does that sound right?'

N; 'Uh, minions I tell you.'

'So you don't even tell your brigade that has almost 750 vehicles and 2,500 personnel to control the battlefield when they are engaged but you expect a 6 vehicle convoy containing 34 Marine personnel to do that????? You really have great respect for the fighting prowess of the United States Marine Corps don't you Colonel?'

N; 'YOU'RE GODDAMN RIGHT I ORDERED THE CODE RED, AND I'D DO IT AGAIN!!'

Last edited by MailBuoy; 25 January 2008 at 23:57.
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old 26 January 2008, 04:32
iraqgunz's Avatar
iraqgunz iraqgunz is offline
Overseas Gunplumber
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Warm and sunny Arizona
Posts: 5,812
Mailbuoy,

Forget Barry Scheck or Allen Dershowitz. If I ever need a lawyer I am calling your ass in a heartbeat.
__________________
"The Armies of our ancestors were lucky, in that they were not trailed by a second army of pencil pushers".

I have been to some armorer courses.

Owner- Semper Paratus Arms, LLC
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old 26 January 2008, 05:16
sawbones sawbones is offline
Confirmed User
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: OH/AZ TRAVEL NURSE
Posts: 732
If this choad ever left the FOB I would pray he was hit by an AD
__________________
"You may be younger and faster but I will still knock you smooth the F**K OUT if you do that again"-HMCS H. (DAD)

Blunt force and penetrating trauma are very educational tools-ME :D

There's only 2 ways to change someones mind about you, setting them on fire or slapping the shit out of them-Marcus Luttrell
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Our new posting rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:14.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Socnet.com All Rights Reserved
SOCNET