Sgt Dakota Meyer

[Dino0311]

I've seen a cook get one for meritoriously cooking chow in the field. Meanwhile, nobody on the super squad that went to division got anything. But e could go on like this all day.

[Spinner]

Originally Posted by Massgrunt

I've seen a cook get one for meritoriously cooking chow in the field. Meanwhile, nobody on the super squad that went to division got anything. But e could go on like this all day.

In Halberstam's book about the early days of the Korean War, The Coldest Winter, there's a passage which recounts the commander of X Corps, Edward Almond, showing up on the battlefield after some unit had just taken horrendous losses and insisting that some men be gathered to receive Silver Stars.

Just to get him out of their hair, the Colonel in charge gathered some people at random, including a cook who had no idea what it was about, and Almond unceremoniously pinned the Silver Stars on their uniform, including that of one officer who had taken some terrible losses.

When he left, the officer who'd lost a lot of men took his Silver Star off and just threw it in the snow. No followup on what the cook did with his.

[Miami Sam]

Originally Posted by Massgrunt

I've seen a cook get one for meritoriously cooking chow in the field. Meanwhile, nobody on the super squad that went to division got anything. But e could go on like this all day.

The Bronze has always been an ambiguous thing because it's perceived by the public as an award for valor whether its got the "V" or not. I wish they'd find another way of honoring administrative performance.

I think Sgt Meyer deserves all the salutes he gets.

Audie Murphy and a number of others found out that living with the MOH is sometimes harder than having died for it.